The latest personnel shortage to make the newspapers popped
up in the Police Department, which had taken shortcuts in its background checks
of applicants to the Police Academy. It appears that, ere long, some of New
York’s finest will have petty-crime convictions-but perhaps that will prove of
assistance to them when “relating” to the criminals they are charged with
capturing and putting in cages.
I’m never sure what the word “relating” means. In this case,
I hope it doesn’t indicate such a strong affinity with law-breakers that the
new police officers, instead of arresting the malefactors, decide to go into
business with them. The possibility is not mere satirical fancy. The history of
metropolitan police forces, including New York’s, is heavy with examples of crooks
in blue, the most recent of which occurred in Washington, D.C., where, a few
years ago, they dropped hiring standards and soon regretted it.
The newspaper reports allude to lowering the physical
qualifications for matriculating at the Police Academy. This and other
allegations of a dilution in the quality of recent candidates is denied by
officialdom, but what are their denials worth? While the Mayor and the rest of ‘em are telling us not to worry, we can be
pardoned for wondering what happens with police officers who are too weak, too
inept or too cowardly to wade in and grab evildoers by the scruff of the neck
and hurl them into the back of a paddy wagon. If cops dare not go hand-to-hand
with crooks and riotous individuals, they will wind up using cattle prods,
pepper spray and mace, or batons and guns. Or they’ll run away.
Difficulty in recruiting people for indispensable
occupations is not confined to the police of New York City. A number of
correctional facilities, or what we used to call jails and prisons, are running
short on guards, and replacing them isn’t easy.
As the teacher shortage gets worse, the administrators are
getting more ingenious. Do you remember last year’s Board of Education
recruitment ads in the subways, telling the riders that “Four out of five
fourth graders in our city’s most challenged schools fail to meet state
standards in reading and writing. Are you willing to do something about it?”
School officials in cities all over the country are
importing teachers, sight unseen, from Chile, China, Russia, France, Hungary,
Australia, Austria, New Zealand, South Africa and the Philippines. God only
knows how many of them speak decent English, but it’s gotten to the point any
warm body in front of the classroom will have to do.
The New York Times
has reported on the uncertain future of vocational training in the New York
public schools: retiring teachers can’t be replaced, enrollments are dropping,
and there are new demands on students to pass what are, for inexplicable
reasons, called “academic tests.” A well-run vocational school ought to be able
to include all the academics any man or woman needs. Benjamin Franklin educated
himself while apprenticed to learn the printing trade, and H. L.
Mencken-belletrist and patron saint of newspapering-went to a Baltimore trade
school and not the Columbia School of Journalism.
elderly masons, machinists with just the slightest palsy of the hand-the
tradesmen of America are visibly aging. While business is energetically forcing
early retirement on thousands of white-collar workers who perhaps were never
needed, cabinet-makers, electricians and air-conditioning technicians are
subjected to the cajoling blandishments of people begging them to postpone
retirement since they are the next thing to irreplaceable.
And then behold the career of one Vickie L. Milazzo,
formerly a critical-care nurse and now a lawyer and founder of Medical-Legal
Consulting Institute Inc., a company that teaches registered nurses how to help
lawyers sue other nurses, doctors, hospitals, insurance and drug companies, and
anybody or anything else from whom money can be gotten. Legal nurse
consultants-the name the enterprising Ms. Milazzo has given this new
occupation-make up to $150 an hour, compared to nursing nurses, who receive
around $20 an hour.
The dearth of competent
nursing care has made a trip to the hospital as frightening as it is dangerous.
Of the tens of thousands who needlessly perish every year, some significant
fraction of those deaths by neglect, accident, gratuitous infection, etc., are
traceable to the ever-shrinking size of the nursing corps. Isn’t it odd how we
are overwhelmed by clouds of flea-bitten persons with papers attesting to their
being practitioners of one sort of questionable therapy or another, but on the
cancer ward, there aren’t enough professionals to cover all the shifts?
Going to vocational school and learning a trade or a craft
has been discouraged by the round-the-clock propaganda about everybody going to
college. Endless lectures about how working with your hands is unworthy and how
anybody who does it is a dumb cluck have taken their toll. Young people have
been taught that scores of useful occupations are unworthy of them. And if
there was any doubt about how little occupations like teaching and nursing are
valued, compare the pay scales, not to mention the respect given to those in
other occupations whose utility escapes immediate appreciation. Stock analysts,
C.E.O.’s of money-losing companies, grief counselors, deputy assistant
deputies, conflict-resolvers, students of trends, anyone referred to as a “guru,” experts on the two-daddy family,
drug czars and inhuman resource directors are among the scores of pseudo
occupations drawing money, prestige and attention away from the recruitment and
retention of people we must have.
Fifty years ago, the assurance that society was training
people in the occupations and specialties it needed was the federal
government’s responsibility, carried out through the Selective Service System.
Boys and men engaged in work the government didn’t deem essential to the
running of things got put in the army. Those studying or doing essential things
were selected not to serve and, in some instances, given financial help to
continue their schooling. The manipulation and shaping of the manpower pool was
called “channeling,” a word which today has a different and intellectually
The rationale for this kind of planning was the struggle
against Communism, but the Selective Service System’s pattern of draft
exemptions showed its priorities were anything but narrowly military. It had
more than a passing interest in the health of the whole society.
Channeling is gone with the Cold War that used to justify
it, and in its place we have nothing except the obdurate assertion that, by the
action of a never-described alchemic process, the needs of the commonweal are
served. “Commonweal” is a word seldom heard in a society whose heroes are those
mud-bespattered champions who have emerged with the loudest oink and the big
ego of individualism-gone-amok. And so we have ever-growing surpluses of that
which we don’t need, and ever-shrinking shortages of that which we do.
Our best-run companies and other institutions plan, plan and
plan all the time-which can’t be easy in a society that has no goals except
getting bigger. Without the compulsion of the Selective Service System, many
ways can be found to channel people into vital occupations. For example,
student loans and grants might be restricted: make fields like law and finance
and cinema ineligible for student aid, and go the other way for those studying
in the fields where we actually need people. For once, the tax laws might be
manipulated in favor of useful occupations and services.
I don’t know how you get people to think about what’s
happening to them. Perhaps next winter, when yet more parents see that there
aren’t even any substitute teachers, not to instruct, but to baby-sit their
children; or perhaps when a relative lies for four hours, unattended, on an
emergency-room gurney; or perhaps while wondering what condition the basement
will be in when the plumber comes-if he comes-in four days … perhaps then it
may finally occur to some that matters are a bit askew. In the meantime, none
for all and all for none.
Follow Nicholas von Hoffman via RSS.