The New York Observer
  • Betabeat
  • Politicker
  • GalleristNY
  • Commercial
  • VSL
  • PolitickerNJ
  • Observer
  • Betabeat
  • Politicker
  • GalleristNY
  • Scene

The New York Observer

Follow @NewYorkObserver

Carrie Bradshaw’s Headed Back to TV—But Who Should Play Her?

LAST
/
NEXT
By Daniel D'Addario 1/20/12 9:00am
Next in Observer

City Hikes Google's Taxes in Chelsea by $3.9 M.

  • Taylor Swift--Writer Carrie
    Start The Slideshow

    Word has it that Sex and the City is getting rebooted on TV–bringing back Carrie Bradshaw for a generation unfamiliar with her exploits! Carrie’s going to be a young writer struggling to make it in New York in a pilot ordered by the CW, as opposed to a youngish writer magically making it in New York. Which actress can portray the young Ms. Bradshaw with just the right mix of panache, narcissism, and ability to wear a Manolo? We have a few suggestions!










     

     

  • Back Forward Ashlee Simpson--Narcissist Carrie

    Ashlee Simpson--Narcissist Carrie

    This actress/singer/mainly actress, we guess, has a history with the CW, having been a star of the 'Melrose Place' update, and also has a Bradshavian way with the narcissist revisionist narrative. Who can forget the manner in which she rewrote her 'Saturday Night Live' lip-synching embarrassment as a triumphant plotline on her own reality show? Everyone can forget it, you say? Either way, it's good on-the job training for playing a woman able to revise a week-old embarrassment into a triumph of love.

  • Back Forward Elizabeth Olsen--Contemplative Carrie

    Elizabeth Olsen--Contemplative Carrie

    If the producers want a Carrie haunted by an enigmatic past and looking into an uncertain future, they could do worse than this star, who's previously portrayed aberrant behavior and sisterhood with cultishly devoted pals in a recent 'cult' movie. 'Martha Marcy May Marlene'? More like 'Carrie Carrie Carrie Carrie'!

  • Back Forward Mary-Kate Olsen--Fashion Carrie

    Mary-Kate Olsen--Fashion Carrie

    Carrie's devotion to fashion can perhaps only be mirrored by a young lady who's spent her entire adult life trying to look yet worse each day in the pursuit of magazine covers. What better way to differentiate Mary-Kate from Ashley than by casting one of the two as a famous character for which M-K wouldn't even have to de-scraggle her hair? (And it's time to capitalize on the buzz Mary-Kate earned by being nominated for a Daytime Emmy over Ashley--that's true.)

  • Back Forward Rooney Mara--Edgy Carrie

    Rooney Mara--Edgy Carrie

    Carrie Bradshaw probably went through a vaguely Euro cyberpunk phase, right? Set 'The Carrie Diaries' in the early 1990s, make Carrie an ahead-of-her-time hacker who simply 'has to wonder' about how easy it is to seduce and steal secrets from banking executives while Trent Reznor's cover of the 'Sex and the City' theme plays, and you've got yourself a show!

  • Back Forward Carey Mulligan--Mopey Carrie

    Carey Mulligan--Mopey Carrie

    We know Carrie gets pretty sad, sucking the entire series into a vortex of dull depression, when she breaks up with Big once every two seasons. But what if that 'Shame' spiral was constant? What if Carrie was constantly plumbing new depths of sadness, surfacing just to glumly smirk at Samantha and tell her she's really fine, really? Sounds like a hit!

  • Back Forward Blake Lively--Gossipy Carrie

    Blake Lively--Gossipy Carrie

    Let's be honest, part 1 of 2: Blake Lively will never do better in her career than 'Gossip Girl.' Let's be honest, part 2 of 2: 'Serena van der Woodsen' is aged-down Carrie Bradshaw with double the fur coats and half the years spent chemically treating her hair. We'll run through a few more options, but Blake should be looking forward to some calls from the same CW executives who keep renewing her show.

  • Back Forward Keira Knightley--Crazy Carrie

    Keira Knightley--Crazy Carrie

    We think the one thing that could have been improved about Carrie is if she jutted her jaw out madly every time Aidan toyed with her emotions. With a framing device about Carrie's shrink helping her get over heartbreak, Keira Knightley could continue her performance as this pathological, emotionally manipulative, addicted-to-pain and yet hyper-ashamed character from "A Dangerous Method"--she'd just need to subtract the jut of the jaw to convince us she was really Carrie.

  • Back Taylor Swift--Writer Carrie

    Taylor Swift--Writer Carrie

    This individual boasts Sarah Jessica Parkerian super-curly hair--and an ability to write lacerating phrases about every gent who wrongs her, an ability made the more useful for her laserlike ability to find exactly the wrong guy each time. Scratch Blake Lively. If Taylor Swift ever wants to get even more into fashion than simply posing for a 'Vogue' cover and also act a bit, she could play this part. We simply have to wonder if she'll take it!

Comments

  1. Bramrox says:
    January 20, 2012 at 7:33 pm

    SHE’S PERFECT!!! YEP mary kate is da one!

  2. mmhm says:
    January 21, 2012 at 2:11 am

    You should get an unknown actress, like a rookie

  3. Happier4me says:
    February 9, 2012 at 5:24 pm

    Blake Lively or Ashlee Simpson were GREAT choices! 

  4. Rosesong55 says:
    February 11, 2012 at 3:02 am

    I am a writer (on the side) and I feel one and the same with Carrie. I feel I could really play her. Would you interview a very “competitive rookie?”

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Reddit
  • Google +1
  • Email
  • Print

Culture

Send

If you'd like us to follow up in regard to this tip, please remember to leave some form of contact information.

Send

Most Popular

Betabeat

Mayoral Candidates Sound Pretty Skeptical of Regulation-Skirting ‘Disruptors’MIT’s New Robot Cheetah Is a Better Cheetah Than Real CheetahsWho Run the Universe? Half of NASA’s New Crop of Astronauts Are Women

PolitickerNY

Mayoral Candidates Sound Pretty Skeptical of Regulation-Skirting ‘Disruptors’State Legislature Moves to Ban Novelty LightersRubén Díaz Thinks Jeff Klein Is ‘Eating All the Candies’

GalleristNY

‘Martial Raysse: 1960–1974′ at Luxembourg & DayanWhere Do We Go From Here?: Critics Lament the State of Art, but Things Are Looking Up in New Books‘Subliming Vessel: The Drawings of Matthew Barney’ at the Morgan Library & Museum

Media

Michael Hastings Dies In Car AccidentMichael Cooper Moves to The Times Culture DeskFacebook Is Almost a Decade Old and Still Doesn't Get the Advertising Game

Real Estate

Alms for the Upper Middle Class: Subsidized Apartments Aim at $200K Earners10 Madison Square West Interiors: A Study In Classy NeutralsOn the Market: NYU Helps Finance Academics' Summer Homes; Nobody Likes SeaPort City; BAM South to Move Forward

Culture

To Error Is Human: The Slapstick Shakespeare in the Park Is IrresistibleStare Thee Well: Eye-Gazing Parties Aren't Just for Pick-Up Artists AnymoreWrite Man in the Palais: Michael Azerrad's New Site Brings DIY Ethos and Peer Review to Music Criticism

Opinion

The Next FloodWaste NotKeep the City Safe

Commercial Observer

City and NYU-Poly Announce Dumbo ‘Clean Tech’ IncubatorJack Terzi of JTRE on Growing, OrganicallyNew York Media Signs Direct Lease at One Hudson Square
Subscribe to The Observer

Across the Wire

  • sad

    Michael Hastings Dies In Car Accident

  • Housing for All

    Alms for the Upper Middle Class: Subsidized Apartments Aim at $200K Earners

  • Up & Down the Street

    The Return of Wall Street’s Cassandra: In Armani and Pearls, Meredith Whitney Smacks Back

  • theater

    To Error Is Human: The Slapstick Shakespeare in the Park Is Irresistible

  • Race to Gracie Mansion 2013

    55% of New Yorkers Can't Name a Single Mayoral Candidate

    • Classifieds
    • Job Listings
    • Legal Advertising
    • Subscriptions
    • About Us
    • Advertising
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Service
Powered by WordPress.com VIP
Cancel
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.