A Selection of Reviews Calling Act of Valor a Recruitment Film

120223063819 act of valor story top A Selection of Reviews Calling Act of Valor a Recruitment FilmAs The Observer noted yesterday, the new action film Act of Valor was intended as a recruitment film for the U.S. Navy SEALs. Film critics seem to have caught on! Herewith, a list of critics who’ve caught on to the military’s game:

  • “Unsurprisingly, the finished product plays like a pumped-up recruitment commercial deemed fit for feature length and multiplex viewing.” —Jeannette Catsoulis, The New York Times
  • “As a no-holds-barred recruiting video, Act of Valor kicks all sorts of ass. As an actual movie, however, it barely coheres.” —Bilge Ebiri, New York
  • “A mechanically efficient yet soulless dramatization of the U.S. Navy SEALs in action, “Act of Valor” ultimately misses its target: The hearts and minds of American audiences.” —Robert Koehler, Variety
  • “In Act of Valor, a recruitment poster loosely disguised as a movie, the story is fictional but the leading men are not.” —Rick Groen, The Globe and Mail
  • “Considering Act of Valor is, at its heart, a multi-million-dollar U.S. military recruitment video, it’s fitting that the film opens with a commercial message from directors Mike ‘Mouse’ McCoy and Scott Waugh.” —Linda Barnard, Toronto Star
  • “A Navy recruitment poster riding a wave of well-deserved Navy SEAL enthusiasm, “Act of Valor” arrives disguised as a feature.” —James Verniere, Boston Herald
  • “The U.S. Navy should slash its recruiting budget and just schedule screenings of Act of Valor. Hollywood meets propaganda in this rah-rah action film about an elite group of Navy Seals who circle the globe battling terrorism.” —Leah Rozen, The Wrap
  • “The question: What is it? Is it a documentary? A docudrama? A rescue mission re-enactment? A lengthy commercial from the Navy’s PR department? No, yes, sort of and yes.” —Clint O’Connor, Cleveland Plain Dealer
  • “Having a real Navy SEAL team as the stars of a fictional action adventure film adds a frightening realism to the traditional shoot-em-up Act of Valor. Michael Bay has some serious competition now that Act of Valor co-directors Mike McCoy and Scott Waugh have upped the ante on military action films.” —Justin Craig, Fox News
Article continues below
More from Politics
Queens Congresswoman Grace Meng and Bronx Assemblyman Michael Blake at the Democratic National Committee meeting in Atlanta.
NYC Congresswoman and Assemblyman Score DNC Vice Chairmanships