New York Times Crossword Guru Will Shortz Needs to Get to Know More Rappers

willshortz e1328543739840 New York Times Crossword Guru Will Shortz Needs to Get to Know More RappersAh, yes: The Monday New York Times crossword puzzle, routinely mocked by seasoned crossword freaks as the province of entry-level puzzle-doers and amateur intellects. In today’s puzzle, however, those who regularly frequent the blank box page may observe an interesting redundancy, and on a technical level, an inaccuracy. Involving rappers.

The final clue to today’s puzzle, by Tom Pepper, solvable with a three-letter answer:

“63. Hip-hop’s ___ Def.”

As blogger and columnist Phillip Bump notes, the same clue appeared back in November. The puzzle, by Jeremy Newton and Tony Orbach, ran on Sunday, November 13, 2011 with the clue to a three-letter answer being:

“113. Hip-hop’s ___ Def.”

[Before we proceed any further, it may be wise to enlist herein a SPOILER ALERT for the answer out of sympathy for those who may need one, unfortunate folk that they are.]

The answer is clearly Mos Def*. There are at least two other three-letter “Def”-related clue/answer combinations within the realm of hip-hop puzzle makers could potentially consider:

  • Russell Simmons and Rick Rubin’s seminal New York rap label Def Jam.
  • ‘Underground’ rap label Def Jux.

 
….Which goes without mentioning all the other “Def” references in hip-hop (like 90s Atlanta-based rap label So So Def, or the “supergroup” of rappers whose 1998 cover of the Sugarhill Gang’s “Rapper’s Delight” became a hit single, Def Squad) or any of the other possible music-related answers that could go with the word “Def” (“Hi-Def,” “Def Leppard,” etc).

Granted, Will Shortz probably can’t remember every single clue that comes under his purview. Surely, some will repeat themselves. But the answer is technically inaccurate, if not simply outdated: The rapper formerly known Mos Def stopped going by that name last year, which he famously noted in a November 2011 interview with Stephen Colbert.

Furthermore, the crossword section has a recent history with a debatable answers to hip-hop oriented clues.

At the beginning of January, a reader email debating the answer to the clue “Wack, as in hip hop” became the subject of joyously heated debate among the oddly inevitable cross-section of hip-hop fans and seasoned crossword solvers. The answer was “ILLIN.”

straight New York Times Crossword Guru Will Shortz Needs to Get to Know More RappersMost hip-hop fans would tell you that someone who is “ILL” (the neutral-action descriptor of “ILLIN”) is certainly by no means “wack,” though there’s room for debate about the transitive verb’s mostly-positive connotations. The fence-sitters at Gawker weighed in on the final definition of the word as “malleable,” an unfortunate entry in their series of outdated but relatively astute hip-hop punditry.

Also, crossword freaks would argue that an outdated clue from a Sunday puzzle (the week’s most challenging) appearing in a Monday puzzle (the week’s least challenging) undermines the challenge of the original clue. And the truth is, there is no more an accessible def-related answer than the word “Mos,” one of the first Google results for “hip-hop” and “Def.”

Needless to say, the Times should expand its rap-related hip-hop purview. Should Will Shortz decide to take us up on the matter, we’ve made a Spotify playlist in his honor. May the Times‘ crosswords forever be more ‘def,’ less ‘Mos’ from this day forward.

[*Who, full disclosure, is not a fan of The Observer.]

fkamer@observer.com | @weareyourfek

Comments

  1. Guest says:

    Come on. This shows a lack of understanding of basic crossword puzzle grammar.
    (1) “___ Def” can’t be “Def Jam” because the blank comes first. This clue isn’t “Def is somewhere in the name”; it is what it says it is.
    (2) The number of letters is implicitly part of the clue. A three-letter clue “___ Def” can’t be “So So Def” or “Hi Def.”
    (3) Clues don’t have to be currently accurate. “Rapper Notorious ___” can be BIG even though he’s dead (and went by other names at times); “Rapper Snoop _____ Dogg” can be DOGGY even though he’s dropped that part of his name; “Singer ___ Stevens” is fine for CAT.
    (4) Clues don’t have to be unambiguous. “Quarterback Manning” is fine even though there are three of them, and would be fine even if they had the same letter count. “First name in Super Bowl quarterbacking” (3 letters) could clue TOM or ELI or lots of others (JOE for Namath, even). Try a Saturday puzzle sometime. Every clue is ambiguous.
    (5) That reminds me, no one who has ever done crosswords would call the Sunday the most challenging. Sat > Fri > Sun >= Thurs > Weds > Tues > Mon.
    (6) There’s no reason not to repeat clues in different puzzles, especially for a three-letter throwaway, especially months apart. MOS is a common set of letters and there are only about three ways to clue it (Mos Def, Mos Eisley [the Star Wars port], and the abbreviation for “months” – the first two really need to have “Def” or “Eisley” in the clue). Three-letter answers often get weak and stereotyped clues.

  2. Jsfry says:

    Sunday puzzle is most challenging? No.