Public Relations Winners and Losers of 2015

Fight for 15

A Fight for $15 protest. (Photo: DON EMMERT/AFP/Getty Images)

Behind every major news story is a raging PR battle. Here’s a highly subjective breakdown of victors and vanquished from this year’s biggest throwdowns.

Winners

Fight for $15
Constant protests and heart-wrenching stories helped turn the tide on increasing the minimum wage for fast-food workers. Big losers: The National Restaurant Association, and some franchisees.

The Humane Society
Would you want your dirty laundry aired on a Times Square billboard? That’s what happened to Costco when the Humane Society broadcast footage of hens being mistreated at one of the discount giant’s egg suppliers. Egg on its face, Costco vowed to sell only cage-free eggs hen(ce).

Tenants
NYC tenants finally fought back against incessant harassment by landlords eager to get rid of them. The city took the renters’ side, promising to end buyout threats and ensure expansion of affordable housing.

White House Press Secretary Jay Carney Resigns, Josh Earnest Replaces Carney

Amazon spokesman Jay Carney. (Photo: Alex Wong/Getty Images)

The New York Times
The paper came out swinging with a damning expose of Amazon’s corporate culture. Times executive editor Dean Baquet and Amazon spokesman Jay Carney duked it out on Medium, with Mr. Carney’s crybaby defense sounding shrill in the face of Mr. Baquet’s hard facts.

Preet Bharara
Mr. Bharara rarely loses, from gaining rights for pet owners in Co-op City, to scoring an independent monitor at Riker’s Island. And as the Observer recently reported, he’s emerging the winner in the battle with Gov. Cuomo over the Moreland Commission debacle.

New York City's Famed Carnegie Deli

The Carnegie Deli. (Photo by Kevin Hagen/Getty Images)

Losers

Carnegie Deli
Deli lovers are wishing this place could give them gas again. An illegal gas hookup last April has kept the Carnegie shuttered. And owner Marian Levine got dragged through a messy, very public divorce trial. To PR reps Nicholas & Lence, we say: Oy, gevalt.

Volkswagen
Will drivers ever feel comfortable getting behind the wheel of “Das Auto” again

United Airlines
Where to begin? United’s nightmares included less-than-smooth integration with Continental, the resignation of CEO Jeff Smisek, acting CEO Oscar Munoz’s mystery-shrouded heart attack, continued contract disputes with flight attendants and accusations of Islamophobia. And, from our experience, they’re never on time.

Opponents of the Hamptons eruv
It’s a complicated issue that raises thorny church/state questions. But opinion pieces opposing the Hamptons eruv—a border that delineates areas of permitted Sabbath activity for observant Jews—got so obsessive as to sound bizarre. The eruv’s supporters won in court. Opponents are still kvetching.

NFL Draft

NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell. (Photo: Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)

NFL
Can Roger Goodell ever get a break? The perpetual loser slipped again when a federal judge overturned his suspension of Tom Brady over Deflategate.

Somerset Partners and the Chetrit Group
The two real estate development companies tried to rebrand the South Bronx as the “Piano District,” but locals criticized the attempt to gentrify the neighborhood. This misguided marketing move became an even bigger fiasco when the two firms hosted a South Bronx party that featured burning trash cans