At the Movies
Articles in At the Movies
Big Movie, Little Budget
August Evening
Running time 127 minutes
Written and directed by Chris Eska
Starring Pedro Castaneda, Veronica Loren, Abel Becerra
Chris Eska’s August Evening, from his own screenplay (in English and Spanish with English subtitles), was reportedly filmed for what is described in the production notes as an ultra-low budget of under $40,000. The 32-year-old Mr. Eska has already won for this, his debut feature film, the 2008 Independent Spirit John Cassavetes Award, given to a feature film with a budget of under $500,000; the Best Film Awards at the Los Angeles and Woodstock Film Festivals; and the Best Ensemble Award from the Los Angeles Film Festival. read more »
C’est Superbe: Guilt, and Gilt, Fill French Holocaust Film
A Secret
Running time 105 minutes
Written by Claude Miller and Natalie Carter
Directed by Claude Miller
Starring Cécile De France, Patrick Bruel, Ludivine Sagnier, Mathieu Amalric
Claude Miller’s A Secret, from a screenplay by Mr. Miller and Natalie Carter, based on Philippe Grimbert’s autobiographical novel Un Secret, retitled in its English translation Memory, a Novel, transcends the perhaps perceived banality of still another film about the Holocaust with a marvelously nuanced narrative floating through time with memorable characters who never beg for our pity. Yet it touches on the ultimate horror of this insane period in world history by focusing not so much on the toll taken of the dead, but on the toll taken of the living survivors wracked with their life-blighting guilt. read more »
Two from the Vault
Carl Theodor Dreyer’s Day of Wrath (Vredens Dag) (1943), from a screenplay by Dreyer, Paul Knudsen and Mogens Scot-Hansen, is being shown in a new 35mm print from New Digital Restoration in a special one-week run at IFC Center from Aug. 29 to Sept. 4. The film was shot in Nazi-occupied Denmark in the midst of World War II, and Dreyer fled Denmark shortly after the film was released. Hence, Day of Wrath was subsequently analyzed in some quarters as Dreyer’s allegory on the oppressive German occupation of Denmark. Be that as it may, it remains today a fierce attack on 17th-century religious intolerance and witch-hunting. read more »
Half and Half
A Girl Cut in Two (Li Fille Coupee en Deux)
Running time 115 minutes
Written by Claude Chabrol and Cécile Maistre
Directed by Claude Chabrol
Starring Ludivine Sagnier, François Berléand, Benoit Magimel
Claude Chabrol’s A Girl Cut in Two (Li Fille Coupée en Deux), from a screenplay by Mr. Chabrol and Cécile Maistre, is the 51st film of Mr. Chabrol’s illustrious career, which began on an unusually high note with Le Beau Berge in 1958. Mr. Chabrol, now 78, once remarked that when confronted with the endless palaver about the French New Wave, of which he was one of the charter members from Cahiers du Cinema: “There are no Waves, New or otherwise, there is only the ocean. read more »
The Long Goodbye
My Mexican Shivah
Running time 98 minutes
Written by Alejandro Springall and Jorge Goldenberg
Directed by Alejandro Springall
Starring Sergio Kleiner, Blanca Guerra, Raquel Pankowsky, Sharon Zundel
Alejandro Springall’s My Mexican Shivah, from a screenplay by Jorge Goldenberg and Mr. Springall, based on a story by Ilan Stavans, is another of the recent examples of the Jewish Diaspora absorbed in the preservation of its identity and its rituals in countries around the world. As its title indicates, My Mexican Shivah is all about the seven-day mourning period after the death of a loved one. In this instance, grandfather Moishe (Sergio Kleiner), a patriarchal community’s life of the party, drops dead after cavorting to the noisy rhythms of a mariachi band. read more »
Czech Me In! WWII Film Makes Honest, Funny, Devastating Cinema
I Served the King of England
Running time 120 minutes
Written and directed by Jiri Menzel
Starring Olrich Kaiser, Ivan Bamev, Julia Jentsch
Jiri Menzel’s I Served the King of England, from his own screenplay, based on the novel by Bonumil Hrabal, has been honored as the Czech Republic’s official selection for the 2008 Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film. But despite the grim, Holocaustal period in which the film is set, it is mostly bubbly and ebullient in its stylistic execution. The story begins on a physically absurdist note as a markedly short convict, Jan Dite (Olrich Kaiser), is led out of prison by a much larger guard after being released from 15 years of penal servitude for having collaborated with the Nazis during the German occupation of Czechoslovakia. read more »
Rohmer, Je t’aime
THE ROMANCE OF ASTREA AND CELADON
Running time 109 minutes
Written and directed Eric Rohmer
Starring Andy Gillet, Stephanie Crayencour
Eric Rohmer’s The Romance of Astrea and Celadon (Les Amours d’Astrée et de Céladon), from his own screenplay, is based on Honoré d’Urfé’s 17th-century novel, which itself is set in fifth-century Gaul; it is a pastoral romance involving the shepherds of the Forez plain. This is Mr. Rohmer’s most recent, and reportedly final, film. Actually, it is amazing that Mr. Rohmer, now nearing 90, has remained active and moderately bankable this long in a career that spans more than half a century, from Journal d’un scelerat in 1950 to L’Anglaise et le Duc (The Lady and the Duke) in 2001 and Triple Agent in 2004. read more »
French Connection
Bruce Goldstein has programmed a fantastic five weeks of French film noir and thrillers, spanning 1937 to 2000, and playing from now through Sept. 11 at Film Forum. The series has already begun, but it’s not too late to catch Jean-Pierre Melville’s Le Cercle Rouge (1970), with Alain Delon, Yves Montand and Gian Maria Volonte, on Friday, Aug. 15, and Saturday the 16th at 1, 3:50, 6:40 and 9:30. Jacques Becker’s Touchez pas au Grisbi (1954), with Jean Gabin, Rene Dary, Lino Ventur and Jeanne Moreau, screens on Sunday the 17th at 2:55, 6:35 and 10:15, and Monday the 18th at 2:55; Melville’s Bob Le Flambeur (1955), with Roger Duchesne and Isabelle Corey, plays Sunday at 1, 4:40 and 8:20, and Monday at 1 and 4:40. read more »
Woody’s Busty Muses Make Sweet Spanish Love
VICKY CRISTINA BARCELONA
Running time 96 minutes
Written and directed by Woody Allen
Starring Penélope Cruz, Scarlett Johansson, Rebecca Hall, Javier Bardem
Woody Allen’s Vicky Cristina Barcelona, from his own screenplay, is close to his 40th feature film in an almost 40-year career that began in earnest in 1969 with Take the Money and Run, and has proceeded through the years with more ups and downs, more ins and outs, more breakthroughs and breakups, and more hits and flops than that of any other director I can think of, from any period in film history. Now in his 70s, he has managed to astound me by coming up with one of the most felicitously written, edited, acted and directed romantic comedies of his entire career. read more »
Man Time
SIXTY SIX
Running time 93 minutes
Written by Peter Straughan and Bridget O’Connor
Directed by Paul Weiland
Starring Greg Sulkin, Eddie Marsan, Helena Bonham Carter, Ben Newton
Paul Weiland’s Sixty Six, from a screenplay by Peter Straughan and Bridget O’Connor, based on a story by Mr. Weiland, reminds me of a Brazilian film I saw not so long ago. That film climaxed with Brazil’s victory in the World Cup competition just as Sixty Six commemorates the year that England won the coveted international soccer title. I must say that the Brazilian movie on the subject had a more interesting political subtext than Sixty Six, which has been subtitled in the production notes as A True…ish Story, and is reportedly patterned after Mr. read more »
Sir Ben Kingsley Plays Roth’s Concupiscent Kepesh as Cruz Nudes Up
ELEGY
Running time 108 minutes
Written by Nicholas Meyer
Directed by Isabel Coixet
Starring Penélope Cruz, Ben Kingsley, Patricia Clarkson, Peter Sarsgaard
Isabel Coixet’s Elegy, from the screenplay by Nicholas Meyer, based on the short novel The Dying Animal by Philip Roth, enters a metaphysical region between life and death that few films have ever dared to explore. Ms. Coixet and Mr. Meyer have managed to capture much of the bittersweet humor of Mr. Roth’s brilliant confrontation of old age, his own included. The director and the scenarist are aided in no small measure by a very accomplished cast headed by Ben Kingsley as David Kepesh, Mr. read more »
Smugglers' Blues
FROZEN RIVER
Running time 97 minutes
Written and DIRECTED BY Courtney Hunt
Starring Melissa Leo, Misty Upham
Courtney Hunt’s Frozen River, from her own screenplay, plays out as one of the strongest feminist statements I have ever seen onscreen. Her two major characters, Ray (Melissa Leo), an abandoned trailer-park wife with two children, and Lila (Misty Upham), a similarly abandoned wife, whose mother-in-law has “stolen” her baby son, join forces in an alien-smuggling partnership across the frozen ice of the St. Lawrence River. Their alliance, formed out of desperate economic hardship, has a very rocky beginning, as Ray accuses Lila of stealing her husband’s car, which has been parked outside a Mohawk Reservation Bingo Hall with cash prizes. read more »
Midnight Kiss Makes Me Salty-Tongued for Indie Film Once More
In Search of a Midnight Kiss
Running Time 90 minutes
Written and DIRECTED BY Alex Holdridge
Starring Scoot McNairy, Sara Simmonds, Katie Luong, Brian Matthew McGuire
Alex Holdridge’s In Search of a Midnight Kiss, from his own screenplay, regards démodé downtown Los Angeles with the same fiercely lyrical affection Woody Allen has lavished on Manhattan over the decades. This alone would make the film strikingly original, but in addition, its tempestuous love story, with its heartbreaking complications, is well served by a cast of comparative unknowns. This talented assemblage is headed by Scoot McNairy as Wilson, the director’s alter ego, and Sara Simmonds as Vivian, the salty-tongued blind date who leads Wilson on a wild frolic across the well-worn streets of a part of Los Angeles that has known better days and years and decades. read more »
Brideshead Revisited, Revisited! Lush Southern Wedding Throws Me for Loop!
BRIDESHEAD REVISITED
RUNNING TIME 135 minutes
WRITTEN BY Jeremy Brock and Andrew Davies
DIRECTED BY Julian Jarrold
STARRING Matthew Goode, Ben Whishaw, Emma Thompson, Hayley Atwell, Greta Scacchi, Michael Gambon
Julian Jarrold’s Brideshead Revisited, from a screenplay by Jeremy Brock and Andrew Davies, is based on the seductively class-ridden novel by Evelyn Waugh. This literary masterpiece has, strangely, never been made into a movie, though it was the source of a popular 12-hour television miniseries that aired in 1981, with Jeremy Irons, Anthony Andrews and Diana Quick in the lead roles now assigned to British newcomers Matthew Goode, Ben Whishaw and Hayley Atwell. read more »
Joke’s On Us: Nolan’s Noir Is Gloomy Echo of New York in 2008
THE DARK KNIGHT
RUNNING TIME 152 minutes
WRITTEN BY Christopher Nolan and Jonathan Nolan
DIRECTED BY Christopher Nolan
STARRING Christian Bale, Heath Ledger, Michael Caine, Aaron Eckhart, Maggie Gyllenhaal, Gary Oldman and Morgan Freeman
Christopher Nolan’s The Dark Knight, from a screenplay by Jonathan Nolan and Christopher Nolan, based on a story by Christopher Nolan and David S. Goyer, is, of course, ultimately from a series of comic books published by DC Comics, with the creation of the Batman character attributed to Bob Kane. In the world of comic-book superheroes, the Batman franchise has specialized in the most eccentrically colorful villains. I still remember Michael Keaton’s Bruce Wayne/Batman character looking out of the corner of his eye at Jack Nicholson’s clownish antics as the Joker in Tim Burton’s 1989 Batman, the second such cinematic transfer after Laslia Martinson’s 1966 Batman, with Adam West reprising in a campy fashion his hit television role. read more »
Sex and Sensibility
I finally caught up with that much abused chick flick, Sex and the City, directed by Michael Patrick King, from his own screenplay, based on characters from the book by onetime New York Observer columnist Candace Bushnell. I happened to have been a steady patron if not a rabid fan of the half-hour television series. How did the two-hour-plus movie compare with the HBO series? As the French would say, pas mal. It started slowly and unpromisingly in a giggly fantasy fashion, and when I use the term “fashion,” I do so advisedly. But when Sarah Jessica Parker is left at the alter by Chris Noth, all the pathos of a rejected 40-year-old woman floods her face with a burst of Zolaesque realism. read more »
Play Ball
Diminished Capacity
Running time 92 minutes
Written by Sherwood Kiraly
Directed by Terry Kinney
Starring Matthew Broderick, Alan Alda, Virginia Madsen, Dylan Baker, Bobby Cannavale, Louis C. K.
Terry Kinney’s Diminished Capacity, from a screenplay by Sherwood Kiraly, is based on Mr. Kiraly’s gentle and yet hilariously hectic novel spoofing the insane predilections of people entangled in the mania surrounding the hunt for an obscure baseball card of a Chicago Cubs player from the early days of our national pastime. Again, as with The Wackness, for a low-budget project, Diminished Capacity is blessed with a blue-ribbon cast. Most notably, Matthew Broderick as brain-damaged Cooper, a downward-drifting Chicago journalist, and Virginia Madsen as Charlotte, a spunky, divorced mother of one and Cooper’s former flame in their hometown, LaPorte, Mo. read more »
Hip-Hop Hooray
The Wackness
Running time 110 minutes
Written and directed by Jonathan Levine
Starring Josh Peck, Ben Kingsley, Olivia Thirlby, Famke Janssen
Jonathan Levine’s The Wackness, from his own screenplay, takes place in New York during the summer of 1994, when the newly inaugurated mayor, Rudy Giuliani, was beginning his now notorious crackdown on all sorts of petty crimes and even mere nuisances. His name is taken in vain several times during the course of the narrative, as if he and he alone were responsible for taking all the fun out of the Lindsay/Dinkins Fun City. Still, “fun” is spelled for the most part as D-O-P-E to the musical accompaniment of the hip-hop rants of the period. read more »
I’m Gonzo for Gonzo! Thompson Doc Made Me Wish I Knew the Guy
Gonzo: The Life and Work of Hunter S. Thompson
Running time 118 minutes
Written and directed by Alex Gibney
Starring Hunter S. Thompson, Johnny Depp
Alex Gibney’s Gonzo: The Life and Work of Dr. Hunter S. Thompson, narrated by Johnny Depp, gets so far inside the tortured soul of its subject through his writings, musings and media sightings that it is amazing how much of the outside world breaks in to illuminate the political and social convulsions Hunter both reported and embodied. Indeed, Gonzo turns out to be the most absorbing film, fiction or nonfiction, I have seen this year. read more »
Dangerous Liaisons

The Last Mistress (Une Vieille Maitresse)
Running time 104 minutes
Written and directed by Catherine Breillat
Starring Fu’ad Ait Aattou, Asia Argento, Roxane Mesquida, Claude Sarraute
Catherine Breillat’s The Last Mistress (Une Vieille Maitresse), from her own screenplay, is based on Jules Barbey d’Aurevilly’s provocative 19th-century novel, and is her most ambitious undertaking to date in terms of a formal narrative with period costumes and a targeted mainstream audience. Hence, most of the nudity and sexuality are deferred to the film’s climax, in which a penniless and newly married aristocrat discovers that his passion for an old discarded mistress can outlast his supposedly eternally true love for a beautiful, virginal and wealthy heiress of noble lineage. read more »
Lady in the Lake
Tell No One (Ne Le Dis à Personne)
Running time 125 minutes
Written by Guillaume Canet and Philippe Lefebvre
Directed by Guillaume Canet
Starring Francois Cluzet, Marie-Josée Croze, Marina Hands, Kristin Scott Thomas
Guillaume Canet’s Tell No One (Ne Le Dis à Personne), from a screenplay (in French with English subtitles) by Mr. Canet and Philippe Lefebvre, is based on a best-selling American mystery novel—Tell No One. Whereas the book was set in New York, the film was shot in Paris with many changes from its literary source. In its present form, it is as much a love story as a murder mystery, with more than its share of Hitchcockian quirks and surprises. read more »
The Hollywood Pen: Paean to Trumbo, Labor of Love, Misses Cold War Web
Trumbo
Running time 96 minutes
Written by Christopher Trumbo
Directed by Peter Askin
Starring Joan Allen, Brian Dennehy, Michael Douglas and others
Peter Askin’s Trumbo is based on the play, Trumbo, by Christopher Trumbo, and is clearly a labor of love and ideological affinity for all the Hollywood celebrities who participated in the production. The Hollywood blacklist ensnared the playwright’s father, Dalton Trumbo, and many other talented people in the period of the cold war, the House Un-American Activities Committee, Senator Joseph McCarthy, J. Edgar Hoover and other cruel relics of a bygone era. Trumbo’s withering take on these instruments of his torture could be used as a club against the Bush-Cheney administration for its perceived assault on the Bill of Rights in the name of national security. read more »
London Calling
Brick Lane
Running time 102 minutes
Written by Abi Morgan and Laura Jones
Directed by Sarah Gavron
Starring Tannishtha Chatterjee, Satish Kaushik, Christopher Simpson, Zafreen
Sarah Gavron’s Brick Lane, from a screenplay by Abi Morgan and Laura Jones, is based on the rapturously received 500-page first novel by Monica Ali. The story begins on a sustained lyrical note as teenage Nazneen (Tannishtha Chatterjee) and her little sister Hasina (Zafreen) chase each other across the sensuously photographed rice paddies next to their home in a village in Bangladesh. The musical accompaniment is a melodious Bangladeshi children’s song composed by Jocelyn Pook. read more »
Sorry About That, Chief! Carell, Hathaway Can’t Hold a Shoe to Adams, Feldon
Get Smart
Running time 110 minutes
Written by Tom J. Astle and Matt Ember
Directed by Peter Segal
Starring Steve Carell, Anne Hathaway, Dwayne Johnson
Peter Segal’s Get Smart, from a screenplay by Tom J. Astle and Matt Ember, is based on a satiric television series with characters created by Mel Brooks and Buck Henry. In fact, Mr. Brooks and Mr. Henry are listed in the film’s credits as “consultants.” This leads one to wonder if the timely jabs at an anonymous Bush-like president and a Cheney-like vice president can be attributed at least partly to the Brooks-Henry team. read more »
Charming Chaplin
Charles Chaplin’s Monsieur Verdoux (1947), in a new 35mm print, will be shown at Film Forum for one week, June 13 to June 19, at 2, 4:30, 7 and 9:30. Chaplin (1889-1977) is supported by Martha Raye, Isobel Elsom, Marilyn Nash, Mady Correll, Irving Bacon, William Frawley and Charles Evans. The film was originally titled A Comedy of Murders, and the idea was reportedly suggested by Orson Welles, though it may have also been based on the real-life Parisian serial killer Landru, the subject of several French films.
Chaplin and Raye do a takeoff on the rowboat scene in Josef von Sternberg’s An American Tragedy (1931) that is even funnier than the one Sid Caesar and Imogene Coca performed on television. Chaplin’s stunned reaction to Raye’s signature raucous laughter in a later scene is one of his most hilarious sight gags in the talkie era. Forget the artistically and politically myopic reviews of the time (with the notable exception of James Agee’s complete rave) and its subsequent flop at the box office. It is a masterpiece. See it.
asarris@observer.com
Stalled Stahl
Quid Pro Quo
Running time 82 minutes
Written and Directed by Carlos Brooks
Starring Vera Farmiga, Nick Stahl
Carlos Brooks’s Quid Pro Quo, from his own screenplay, transports us into a strange world of guilt-ridden fetishism by which the legitimately physically handicapped incite envy in a small group of able-bodied eccentrics. The film begins with Nick Stahl’s Issac Knott, a New York City Public Radio reporter, who begins to tell his own personal story, and the mystery that surrounds it, over the airwaves. Isaac has been confined to a wheelchair since surviving an automobile accident that killed both of his parents when he was 8 years old.
The crash itself is never shown over the course of the film, but the scenic approach to the accident is repeated many times, with stunning images of symmetrically arranged plants serving as counterpoint to the shady setting in which the handicapped-wannabes choose to congregate.
Issac is not lacking in his own fetish objects for recovery, most notably a pair of magical shoes that send tremors of feelings up his legs so that he can finally stand on his own power, and with a pair of canes that liberate him from his wheelchair. Another of his fetishes is a Milwaukee brace that also aids his recovery.
For the group that Issac is investigating in his broadcast, his wheelchair is itself a magical means of transforming the non-handicapped into the handicapped. At first I thought that the whole film was becoming an extended sick joke ridiculing all the agitation about supplying access to the handicapped.
But then arrives Vera Farmiga’s Fiona, a beautiful and accomplished woman with a morbid desire to enter what she considers Isaac’s privileged realm of incapacitation. Hence, she is so disappointed when Isaac begins to regain the use of his legs that she steals his shoes for a short time to hinder his recovery. But when she does finally return them, it is with a feeling of terminal resignation, and she disappears shortly thereafter. Isaac tries in vain to find her, but we already know the “secret” of Isaac’s accident, and it plays out like a detective story, with the complete solution to the mystery locked in the detective’s psyche.
The ambitious indirection of the film’s visual style is reflected in the director’s own comment on the direction of his cast: “I told the actors in rehearsal to think of the story as unfolding entirely within that moment that transpires between deep sleep and wakefulness. So from the earliest rehearsals and creative discussions and final sound design, we approached the film within that framework—that the film itself should be experienced as a kind of dream. Even to the extent that we avoided the usual overtly ‘dreamy’ filmmaking and editing tricks—in favor of a straightforward style that would, like an actual dream, invite you to perceive it as real.”
Quid Pro Quo thereby seems to be the latest attempt to awaken us all from more than a century of dreamlike voyeurism at the temples of the cinema so that we can look more closely at the mechanics of our addiction. The effort is as cerebral as all get-out, and it is moderately interesting to think about afterward. Still, there is a limit to how far we will go to forgo the pleasures of the ancient illusionists of the medium. This is to say that Quid Pro Quo is a respectable feature-film debut for Mr. Brooks, and it remains reasonably thought-provoking without ever becoming emotionally absorbing.
asarris@observer.com
Old Dog Does Many Tricks (Sans Viagra!) in Geriatric Sex Flick
Love Comes Lately
Running time 86 minutes
Written and Directed by Jan Schütte
Starring Otto Tausig, Rhea Pearlman, Barbara Hershey, Tovah Feldshuh
Jan Schütte’s Love Come Lately, from his own screenplay, is based on three Issac Bashevis Singer short stories: “The Briefcase,” “Alone,” and “Old Love.” Mr. Schütte has gone above and beyond the call of dutiful adaptation to translate Singer’s world into vibrantly geriatric longings for older women. As Singer notes in his preface to his collection, Old Love, “The love of the old and middle-aged is a theme that is recurring more and more in my works of fiction. Literature has neglected the old and their emotions. The novelists never told us that in love, as in other matters, the young are just beginners and that the art of loving matures with age and experience.”
Austrian actor Otto Tausig, now in his mid-80s, plays prolific author Max Kohn, who finds himself on an Amtrak train on which he is outrageously grilled by the conductor on the number of times he has had sexual intercourse in a week. It seems that if Max doesn’t answer, the conductor will throw him off the train. Max wakes up with a start from this nightmare of his impending impotence, awakening his long-suffering bed partner, Reisel (Rhea Pearlman), who has become increasingly infuriated by Max’s many infidelities.
Max is fashioned in the mold of many recent screen academics and authors who are well past their prime, but continue masochistically on lecture tours to ever emptier auditoriums and lecture halls. But the emphasis here is not on the pathos of his decline, but, rather, on his unending susceptibility to sexual adventures with new female acquaintances. After a typically poorly attended campus visit at which his hosts defensively remind him that he is not a big name like Kafka, Max is consoled by an accidental reunion with a former student named Rosalie, played by a still very scrumptious Barbara Hershey. When they find themselves together in her apartment, with the inevitable about to happen, Max guiltily calls Reisel to cover his tracks, but succeeds only in making her more angrily suspicious.
In a subsequent nightmare, Max is thrown out of a hotel that has suddenly declared bankruptcy, and is forced to move into an empty run-down motel, where he is aggressively pursued by crippled Cuban housekeeper Esperanza (Elizabeth Peña). When he resists her advances, thinking in the dream that he is married, Esperanza storms out in a rage, accusing him of rejecting her because of her infirmity.
The final episode is prompted by the loss of his briefcase with his speech inside, and his substitution of a short story he has written, based on Singer’s “Old Love.” Max, like Singer himself, is a retiree who has moved to Miami Beach. One day a woman knocks on his door and introduces herself as his next-door neighbor, Ethel (Tovah Feldshuh), a recent widow who has enjoyed nothing but happiness with a kind and loving husband, and now feels that he is asking her to join him in the afterlife.
Max gallantly asks her to sit down with him for coffee while they discuss the ways they can spend the rest of their lives. They agree to meet again, but when the time comes, they are separated forever by a message she leaves behind before joining her husband in the great beyond, where they will put in a kind word for poor bereft Max, who is left alone once more on the far side of life.
There have been several other films over the years based on Singer’s works, but none with such relevance as Love Comes Lately to Singer’s own description of his subjects: “I deal with unique characters in unique circumstances …a group of people who are still a riddle in the world and often to themselves—the Jews of Eastern Europe, specifically the Yiddish-speaking Jews who perished in Poland and those who emigrated to the USA. The longer I live with them and write about them, the more I am baffled about the richness of their individuality (since I am one of them) by my own whims and passions. While I hope and pray for the redemption and resurrection, I dare to say that for me, these people are living right now, in literature, as in our dreams, death does not exist.”
Otto Tausig deserves some kind of special award for incarnating the ageless defiance of the death-dealing Nazi Holocaust, which Singer never addressed directly in his writings, but sought to nullify with characters like Mr. Tausig’s indomitable Max Kohn.
asarris@observer.com
Howard Hawks
“Late Hawks” is the provocative title of a retrospective at Anthology Film Archives (32 Second Avenue) that covers the later, more neglected movies of Howard Hawks (1896-1977), plus a few earlier ringers like Red River (1948) and Gentlemen Prefer Blondes (1953). Hawks’ career antedated the talkies—he made the silents The Road to Glory and Fig Leaves, both in 1926—and extended all the way to Rio Lobo, in 1970. He was eventually singled out by his admirers for stylistic consistency; in an interview, he declared that he consciously shot most of his scenes at the eye level of a standing onlooker. A director of parts as well as a unified whole, Hawks stamped his distinctively gritty view of life on adventure, gangster and private-eye melodramas; Westerns; musicals; and screwball comedies—the kind of thing Americans do best and appreciate least. That one can discern the same directorial signature over an unprecedentedly wide variety of genres is proof of his artistry. That one can still enjoy the genres for their own sake is proof of the artist’s professional urge to entertain.
By a not-so-strange coincidence, I am teaching my first course in Howard Hawks this fall semester, after 43 years of being engaged in film studies. Why the long wait? Like his illustrious contemporaries, John Ford and Jean Renoir, he is as difficult to teach as the equally sublime Alfred Hitchcock and Buster Keaton are easy—that is, easier to teach to young people, and easier for young people to appreciate.
The Hawks series begins with Hatari! (1962), with John Wayne, Hardy Kruger, Elsa Martinelli, Bruce Cabot and Red Buttons. It will screen on Wednesday, June 4, at 6:30; Friday, June 6, at 8:30; and Sunday, June 8, at 3:30.
Next up will be Gentlemen Prefer Blondes (1953), with Marilyn Monroe, Jane Russell, Charles Coburn, Tommy Noonan, Elliott Reid and George Winslow. Showtimes are Wednesday, June 4, at 9:30; Friday, June 6, at 6:30; Saturday, June 7, at 9:30; and Sunday, June 8, at 6:30. After that? Land of the Pharaohs (1955), with Jack Hawkins, Joan Collins, Dewey Martin, James Robertson Justice, Alexis Minotis and Sydney Chaplin. It will be shown on Thursday, June 5, at 6:30; Saturday, June 7, at 4; and Sunday, June 8, at 8:30.
Man’s Favorite Sport? (1964), with Rock Hudson, Paula Prentiss, Maria Perschy, John McGiver, Charlene Holt, Roscoe Karns, Norman Alden and Regis Toomey, will screen on Thursday, June 5, at 9:30 and Saturday, June 7, at 7.
Rio Bravo (1959), with John Wayne, Dean Martin, Ricky Nelson, Walter Brennan, Angie Dickinson, Ward Bond, Claude Akins, John Russell, Bob Steele and Harry Carey Jr. screens Wednesday, June 11, at 6:45; Friday, June 13, at 9:15; and Saturday, June 14, at 3:30.
Also on the bill: El Dorado (1966), with John Wayne, Robert Mitchum, James Caan, Charlene Holt, Michele Carey, Arthur Hunnicutt, R. G. Armstrong and Edward Asner. Showtimes are Wednesday, June 11, at 9:30; Saturday, June 14, at 6:30; and Sunday, June 15, at 3:30. And Rio Lobo (1970), with John Wayne, Jorge Rivero, Jennifer O’Neill, Jack Elam, Victor French, Christopher Mitchum, Susana Dosamantes, Mike Henry, David Huddleston, Bill Williams, Sherry Lansing and Jim Davis, on Thursday, June 12, at 6:45; Saturday, June 14, at 9; and Sunday, June 15, at 8:45.
Last but not least: Red River (1948), with John Wayne, Montgomery Clift, Walter Brennan, Joanne Dru, John Ireland, Noah Beery Jr., Paul Fix, Coleen Gray, Harry Carey Jr. and Harry Carey Sr., will be shown Thursday, June 12, at 9:15; Friday, June 13, at 6:45; and Sunday, June 15, at 6.
asarris@observer.com
Don’t Cry for Me, Colin Firth
When Did You Last See Your Father?
Running time 92 minutes
Written by Daniel Nichols
Directed by Anand Tucker
Starring Colin Firth, Jim Broadbent, Juliet Stevenson, Claire Skinner
Anand Tucker’s When Did You Last See Your Father?, from a screenplay by Daniel Nichols, based on Blake Morrison’s book of the same name, fully qualifies as what film historian Raymond Durgnat once designated as a “male weepie.” This is to say that we men who smirkingly condescend to so-called “chick flicks” reach for our handkerchiefs when we are shown a memory scene of a late father teaching his teenage son how to drive.
There is such a scene in When Did You Last See Your Father?, and in the convoluted flashback structure of the narrative, we already know that Jim Broadbent’s Arthur Morrison is dying of cancer, and his 40-year-old son, Colin Firth’s Blake Morrison, a successful author, is recalling all the good and bad times they shared from Blake’s childhood (Young Blake played by Bradley Johnson) to his adolescence (Teenage Blake played by Matthew Beard) to the mournful, tearful present, during which Blake must finally come to terms with his mixed relationship with his exasperating father.
Arthur Morrison and his wife, Kim (Juliet Stevenson), were physicians in the same medical practice in the heart of the Yorkshire Dales, England. They had two children, Gillian (Claire Skinner) and her older brother, Blake. The story covers a period of 40 years in bits and pieces of Blake’s memory of his father, beginning with a summer family drive in the late 1950s. Stymied by a long line of stalled automobiles en route to a car-racing arena, Blake’s father brandishes a stethoscope as he blithely bypasses the line by speeding through the right or, rather, wrong lane, talking down the noisily outraged drivers on the line by lying about a nonexistent medical emergency, and then bluffing his way past the security guard with cheaply invalid tickets just in time to watch the first race. Kim and the children are mortified by Arthur’s nervy behavior, but all they can do is cower in their seats in shame.
On other public occasions, Blake’s father easily dominates the proceedings, even when Blake is given a literary award. Arthur is bitterly disappointed when Blake does not follow him into his medical practice, but Blake has to concede that the recognition he received for his writings did greatly please his father. There are also less savory memories, of the father’s dalliances with other women, and even possibly an illegitimate child. But Kim’s essentially passive attitude through the years of their marriage only clouds her son’s memories without completely darkening them.
This vagueness about the father’s more serious derelictions of marital duty would have counted as a serious flaw in the film if it were not completely overwhelmed by a spectacularly terrific tearjerker ending that, I must confess, even got to me. I have never really seen anything quite like it, and I must therefore wholeheartedly recommend this wondrous work for its magnificently moving father-son performances by Mr. Broadbent and Mr. Firth.
asarris@observer.com
Sean William Scott, John C. Reilly Scan Well in Supermarket Sweep

The Promotion
Running time 85 minutes
Written and Directed by Steve Conrad
Starring Sean William Scott, John C. Reilly, Jenna Fischer, Lili Taylor
Steve Conrad’s The Promotion, from his own screenplay, immerses itself in the world of Chicago supermarket midlevel employees, two of whom are furiously competing for promotion to a better-paying managerial position. At first, longtimer Doug (Sean William Scott) is considered a shoo-in for the promotion, but with the sudden arrival of Richard (John C. Reilly), a newcomer from a Canadian branch of the Donaldson supermarket chain, the competition is thrown open again.
Richard is more gregarious than Doug, and his amiability seems to give him an edge at the outset of their hilariously desperate struggle for advancement. Both men are in their 30s and married, Doug to a medical assistant, Jen (Jenna Fischer), and Richard to a Scottish woman, Laurie (Lili Taylor). Richard and Laurie already have one child, whereas Doug and Jen are still trying to determine if they can afford to buy a house and start a family.
There are none of the usual shenanigans one finds in many current movies about married couples. The stakes are too high for any errant glances in one direction or another. Doug is somewhat irritated with Jen’s employer, Dr. Mark Timms (Bobby Cannavale), a pediatric cosmetic surgeon who is always popping up to boast of a life-changing service he has performed for one afflicted child or another. But there is never the slightest suspicion of any monkey business between Jen and her pompous boss. Indeed what is most different about The Promotion in today’s movie market is its unusual lack of malignancy, to the point that one feels sympathetic to both the apparent protagonist, Doug, and the apparent antagonist, Richard. Then what accounts for the quiet horror of the situation? Dare I say it? It’s the infernal system that tortures and enslaves the great majority of ordinary people.
Mr. Conrad has touched on some sensitive issues, particularly in this wildly contentious election year, by placing Doug and Richard in an impossible quandary: on the one hand is the firm’s insistence on good community relations with even the most rambunctious elements of the minority population; and on the other, the ability of a few delinquents to make Doug and Richard lose their cool at the very moment their superiors choose to arrive on the scene. When the inevitable slips of the tongue do occur, one does not know whether to laugh sadistically or groan sympathetically.
The two wives, Jen and Laurie, are quietly and subtly supportive without indulging the eccentric explosions of their beleaguered husbands. In short, Mr. Conrad has managed to generate humor and drama out of the everyday predicaments of real people without either preaching or fantasizing about some ideal alternative to the money-grubbing world we inhabit.
The talented ensemble players fit seamlessly into the writer-director’s controlled patterns of dispensing information from a variety of viewpoints amid sudden transitions from the impersonal to the subjective. All in all, The Promotion deserves to be remembered fondly when this year’s award season comes rolling around. At last, we have a completely and profoundly American movie with all the classical skills of timing, editing and character development that we associate nostalgically with some Hollywood golden age.
asarris@observer.com
Family Affair
Savage Grace
Running Time 97 minutes
Written by Howard A. Rodman
Directed by Tom Kalin
Starring Julianne Moore, Stephen Dillane, Eddie Redmayne
Tom Kalin’s Savage Grace, from a screenplay by Howard A. Rodman, based on the book Savage Grace by Natalie Robins and Steven M. L. Aronson, fails to explain why its characters, supposedly drawn from real life, behave in the neurotic and psychotic manner shown on the screen. Perhaps there is no adequate explanation for the psychic disasters that befall the Baekeland family. I must say, however, that I received much more insight into the family’s problems from the copious production notes than I did from the film itself. About the only impression I retained from a single viewing of the movie was that of Julianne Moore’s Barbara Baekeland in eternally red dresses, initially vivacious and flirtatious, but perpetually angry underneath, mostly at her cold, upper-crust husband, Stephen Dillane’s Brooks Baekeland, heir to the Bakelite plastics fortune. Caught in the middle of this messed-up marriage is the troubled son, Eddie Redmayne’s Anthony Baekeland, or “Tony” as he was known to his various sexual partners, male, female and, occasionally, his own mother. The time span of the film runs from 1946 to 1972, and is organized into six increasingly unpleasant acts over an oddly foreshortened 97 minutes, a rare instance of less seeming to last much longer.
When asked in an interview what initially attracted him to the project, Mr. Kalin, the director, answered: “Christine Vachon gave me a copy of the book, Savage Grace, by Natalie Robins and M. L. Aronson to read many years ago. I was riveted by the sensational truth at the core of the Baekeland story, but even more by the echoes of classical tragedy. The sad beauty of the material drew me to it. But the film’s terrible climax, Barbara’s death, is only part of her story. The originality of her uniquely American character (self-made woman of the 1940s with a born gambler’s instinct) and her glittering rise and devastating fall contained the elements of what I believed would be an amazing drama.”
Mr. Kalin has received many festival honors around the world for his many offbeat projects since he made his 1992 feature-film debut with Swoon, on the Leopold-Loeb thrill-killing ’20s sensation, with more emphasis than previous treatments on the widespread homophobia at work in the society at large. I suspect that Mr. Kalin and his equally honored screenwriter, Mr. Rodman, assumed a widespread familiarity with their subject that simply did not exist, at least within my own cultural purview.
Mr. Kalin’s own recollection of his partnership with Mr. Rodman on the project is particularly revealing: “I had an amazing collaboration with the writer of the film, Howard Rodman. We both knew the book was too sprawling in its scope for a simple adaptation (Savage Grace consists primarily of first-person accounts of witnesses and participants in the Baekeland saga, spanning nearly a century.) Howard and I began by separately identifying what we considered the five key moments of Barbara’s story. When we compared the results, most of them were the same.”
The problem the creative team never solved was the lack of dramatic construction in the narrative to indicate where the actual turning points occurred over the years. Most of the scenes are oppressively intimate, without any adequate ambience to indicate any social consequences for the erratic behavior of the three major characters. As a comparatively uninformed viewer, I found myself relatively detached from the gruesome climax of the film, and the film’s even more gruesome post-film printed accounts of further disasters in this pathologically afflicted family.
Call me old-fashioned if you wish, but I will continue to expect and even demand more dramatic coherence in my narrative entertainment. It is too easy to avoid banality by depriving the audience of enough information to understand the inner lives of the characters. As it stands, Savage Grace is a film strictly for avant-garde festivals, at which even minimal exposition is at a premium.
Atta Turk! Director Akin Breaking Hearts With Dark Drama

The Edge of Heaven
Running time 122 minutes
Written and directed by Fatih Akin
Starring Baki Davrak, Tuncel Kurtiz, Nursel Köse, Nurgul Yeşilçay, Hanna Schygulla
Fatih Akin’s The Edge of Heaven (Auf der anderen Seite), from his own screenplay in English, German and Turkish with English subtitles, succeeds in transcending an amazing series of coincidences with its compassionate treatment of several transplanted Turkish and German characters, both parents and children, on a not-so-merry-go-round between placid Bremen, Germany, and tumultuous Istanbul. Mr. Akin, the son of Turkish parents, was born and educated in Germany, and on the evidence of his previous film, Head-On (2004), and now The Edge of Heaven, he sees in the clash of the two cultures the dramatic sparks of fiery personal tragedies.
There are two coffins shown being transported to airplanes, one bound from Bremen to Istanbul, and the other from Istanbul to Bremen. Both contain the bodies of vibrant human beings we have come to know before they became victims of grotesque homicides that were nonetheless rooted in their own passions and the passions of the people around them.
The narrative starts and stops arbitrarily between at first seemingly disconnected pieces of time and space, first in Turkey, and then in Germany. Eventually, we are introduced to the major characters, beginning and ending with Nejat Aksu (Baki Davrak), a Turkish-German philosophy professor living and teaching in Bremen. Of course, it is very possible that the seemingly sexless Nejat serves as the writer-director’s alter ago.
Nejat lives in Bremen with his retired pensioner father, Ali Aksu (Tuncel Kurtiz), a lusty, drunken old widower, who persuades a Turkish-speaking prostitute he accidentally encounters to move in with him. The prostitute, Yeter Öztürk (Nursel Köse), is reluctant at first, but when two of her outraged co-religionists threaten her with bodily harm if she doesn’t discontinue her shameful activities, she quickly decides to move in with Ali. Nejat is at first scandalized by his father’s new “living arrangement,” but when he discovers that Yeter is supporting with her earnings a college-age daughter back in Turkey, he becomes more sympathetic to her plight. After suffering a heart attack from which he slowly recovers, Ali angrily and mistakenly suspects that Nejak’s shift in attitude indicates that his son is sleeping with Yeter. One day, when Yeter resists his drunken advances and tries to leave, Ali pushes her to the floor so hard that he accidentally kills her.
While Ali is imprisoned for the murder and later deported back to Turkey, Nejat resolves to abandon his profession and go to Istanbul to find the late Yeter’s daughter, Ayten Öztürk (Nurgul Yeşilçay). Nejat was much too late, however, inasmuch as Ayten, a student revolutionary, had long since fled Turkey after sleeping through a failed street demonstration, and ended up—where else?—in Bremen sleeping through Nejat’s lecture on Goethe.
The distinctive shot of her sleeping through the lecture is shown twice, both before and after we know the identity of the sleeping student. This repetition of images is typical of the film’s narrative strategy. By this constant circling back, the characters become more inevitably driven by their fateful feelings. It is as if an added layer of characterization has been added to the narrative, formally enhancing its impact, and enriching its content.
When Ayten is impulsively befriended by a German student, Lotte Staub (Patrycia Ziolkowska), we already know this relationship will end badly for this newcomer to the story, because this section of the film is titled by the writer-director “Lotte’s Death.” In any event, Ayten and Lotte become impassioned lovers, much to the dismay of Lotte’s at first helplessly bourgeois mother, Susanne Staub, played by Hanna Schygulla, the late Rainer Werner Fassbinder’s muse in nearly half of his 50 films, from the late ’60s to the early ’80s. One of the foremost sensual icons of her time, Ms. Schygulla at 64 still retains her overpowering intensity in her projection of a mother’s grief over the loss of a daughter. Yet, as an integral part of a magnificently talented ensemble, she never diminishes the assorted charisma of the other major characters she encounters. Still, the bereaved mother’s intervention is decisive in consoling and embracing Ayten over the death of their mutually beloved Lotte, and persuading Nejak to rejoin his errant father.
The last image of Nejak sitting on the shore of the Black Sea patiently waiting for this father to return from a fishing trip is held for several minutes all the way to the conclusion of the end credits. It is a haunting expression of the forgiveness and reconciliation that make up the noblest transaction imaginable for children estranged from their parents.
Mr. Akin has created an epical masterpiece centered on otherwise ordinary lives disrupted by the restless movements of whole populations from one domain to another. The Edge of Heaven is Mr. Akin’s eloquent demonstration of the viability of bridging the abyss between two supposedly irreconcilable visions of the earth’s inhabitants at the edge of one heaven or another. Mr. Akin’s own mixed heritage has enabled him to focus on a shared humanity without glossing over the hatreds and bigotries that conspire to keep us all apart. Now, more than ever, The Edge of Heaven is a film to be seen, savored and thoughtfully appreciated.
Selznick Surprise
The Film Society of Lincoln Center, in collaboration with the George Eastman House in Rochester, N.Y., has added an extremely rare archival find to their felicitously conjoined tributes to Jennifer Jones and Charles Boyer. The series has been imaginatively programmed by Joanna Ney, staff programmer for the society. On May 21, a screening of King Vidor’s Duel in the Sun (1946) at 3:30 will be preceded by a nine-minute series of screen tests of Gregory Peck and Jennifer Jones ordered by David Selznick, and conducted by Josef von Sternberg. The illustrious Sternberg was solemnly instructed by Selznick to produce the same intense passion with Peck and Jones that Sternberg had previously achieved with Gary Cooper and Marlene Dietrich in Morocco in 1930. Daniel Selznick will be on hand to tell the full story of the nine-minute screen test. The screening will be held at the Walter Reade Theatre on Amsterdam Avenue and 65th Street.
The Other Brooklyn
SANGRE DE MI SANGRE
Running time 100 minutes
Written and directed by Christopher Zalla
Starring Jorge Adrian Espandola, Jesús Ochoa, Armando Hernández
Christopher Zalla’s Sangre de Mi Sangre (Blood of My Blood), from his own screenplay (in Spanish with English subtitles), has been honored as the first Spanish-language film to win the grand jury prize at the Sundance Film Festival, and one can see why. Though its Mexican immigrant characters express themselves almost entirely in Spanish, the film was actually shot in a lower-class Brooklyn neighborhood with a longingly ironic view of the Manhattan skyline. Most of the footage was rendered with a mobile hand-held camera, and its noirish narrative is antithetical to the feel-good sentimentality of the recent Mexican mother-son reunion in Under the Sam

























