We wonder what bothers all red-blooded men more: that Scarlett Johansson is off the market, or that they could have had a shot with her. After all, the Sexiest Woman/Celebrity of the Year (according to Maxim, Playboy, GQ, etc.,)  has only dated celebs in the past: Sean Penn, Ryan Reynolds, Josh Hartnett, Justin Timberlake (well, that last one was unconfirmed, but still…) and not regular Joes.

Now the world’s discovered that ScarJo’s been dating a 38-year-old ad executive named Nate Naylor for the past five months. And despite having a moniker that’s straight-up Gossip Girl, Mr. Naylor is just like us. He even has a Tumblr! Read More