opinion

Tunnel Vision

When Governor Christie decided that it was a bad idea to build a new rail tunnel underneath the Hudson River, he made it seem like the project figured to become the region’s answer to the Big Dig. That infamous federally funded highway-tunnel project in Boston was budgeted at $2.8 billion in 1982. The final cost was more than $14 billion in 2007.

Mr. Christie insisted that the so-called ARC tunnel (as in Access to the Region’s Core) would cost billions more than the federal government’s estimate of about $8.7 billion, and that New Jersey would have to pay for 70 percent of the project’s cost. So he abruptly cancelled the state’s participation and effectively killed the idea of replacing the antiquated, century-old tunnel that Amtrak and New Jersey Transit currently use.

The U.S. Government Accountability Office recently released a report that indicates that the governor’s posturing was more about politics than it was about accountability. Read More

Planes Trains & Automobiles

Probably the only train Chris Christie ever liked. (Wikimedia Commons)

Surprise! Chris Christie Fudged the Numbers When He Killed the ARC Tunnel

It was the shot heard ’round the Hudson, the anti-spending measure that arguably made New Jersey Governor Chris Christie a national conservative star: Killing the ARC Tunnel.

The move was unprecedented, reversing decades of Robert Moses-inspired shovels-in-the-ground unstoppability for public works. And now it appears to have been little more than a political gambit. The Times has gotten a copy of a new Government Accountability Office report showing that Governor Christie grossly exaggerated the costs his state would bear if it went ahead with the multi-billion project to create a new rail connection between Manhattan and Secaucus. Read More

Planes Trains & Automobiles

They Can’t Even Afford a Second Manhattan Station, But Now the 7 Train Will Stop in Secaucus?

Westward, ho… after all!

In the confusion following the disappearance of the ARC Tunnel last month, the biggest question seemed to be what would happen to the $3 billion the federal government had set aside for the trans-Hudson train tunnel, by certain measures the largest transportation project ever undertaken. Local politicians, including Mayor Bloomberg Read More

Planes Trains & Automobiles

What the F-ARC! Is Everybody Gonna Pull a Christie and Kill Mass Transit?

It looks like New Jersey Governor Chris Christie isn’t the only one playing politics with mass transit funding. WNYC vet Andrea Bernstein had a fascinating yet terrifying–at least for transit geeks–report on Marketplace this morning about how a number of GOP gubernatorial candidates across the country have talked about killing off high-speed rail construction Read More