Lawyers Argue Over Recount in the 20th; No Immediate Ruling

POUGHKEEPSIE—Attorneys representing Jim Tedisco and Scott Murphy met in court today to argue over a procedure for recanvassing voting machines

POUGHKEEPSIE—Attorneys representing Jim Tedisco and Scott Murphy met in court today to argue over a procedure for recanvassing voting machines and counting absentee ballots in the neck-and-neck race to replace Kirsten Gillibrand in Congress.

Sign Up For Our Daily Newsletter

By clicking submit, you agree to our <a href="http://observermedia.com/terms">terms of service</a> and acknowledge we may use your information to send you emails, product samples, and promotions on this website and other properties. You can opt out anytime.

See all of our newsletters

Judge James Brands said he will issue an order this afternoon asking county boards of elections that have not already done so to complete a re-canvass of voting machines, starting tomorrow. Many of the 10 counties comprising the district have already begun or completed this process, which has resulted in fluctuating tallies.

"It makes sense that we try to move this along, in fairness to the candidates, as rapidly as possible," Brands said.

Brands may also rule on whether a federal stipulation stating no military and overseas ballots can be counted before April 13 applies to ballots cast by voters living in the United States.

Henry Berger, an attorney representing Murphy, argued that the counting of absentee ballots already cast and received by boards—there are about 6,000—should not  be delayed by the rule. He said his campaign is ready to start counting absentee ballots—if necessary, in all 10 counties—by tomorrow.

"We're ready to do it tomorrow or Wednesday," he said. "We will provide the staff and make sure we have people available in each of the 10 counties."

Republicans argued that no absentee counting should take place until the 13th.

"We think the count ought to be done fairly, we think every vote should count," said James Walsh, who, along with Michael Cuevas, represented Tedisco. "I don't think quick justice is good justice and I don't think quick counting is good counting."

The hearing was forced by John Ciampoli, who, on behalf of the Republican State Committee obtained an injunction impounding all paper ballots cast in the race.

Another scheduling conference will take place at 10 a.m. on April 13 in Dutchess County Supreme Court, Brands said.

Lawyers Argue Over Recount in the 20th; No Immediate Ruling