Remember the portfolio deal? That’s right, the practice of grouping a bunch of buildings together and selling them all at once? Yep, it’s hard to remember, because the last time a big portfolio deal happened in New York City was …
“Wow,” laughed Pete Culliney, director of Global Research for Real Capital Analytics, when The Observer posed him that question. “Let me dust off the books. Who would imagine that would be the question of the day! In general, portfolios of more than three or four properties are almost nonexistent.”
Mr. Culliney was able to find one—that’s right, one—portfolio transaction in Manhattan this year—a small sale of three apartment buildings in January, for $14.5 million.
In contrast, January of 2008 saw a six-unit Manhattan portfolio sell for $44 million; a nine-property Manhattan portfolio sell for $311 million; a two-unit Manhattan portfolio sell for $20 million; and another two-unit trade for $10 million.
You hear that dolorous sound? It’s the death knell of yet another boom-time practice.
“The portfolio-purchase phenomenon really gained speed because credit flowed like beer at a frat party,” said David Schechtman, a senior director at Eastern Consolidated. “Today, the keg is kicked.”
And frat boys are having less luck with the ladies?
No. “And bite-sized deals prevail,” Mr. Schechtman said.
Examples: Right now, Massey Knakal, which had made a sizable niche for itself in bite-size deals, is marketing a 17-building portfolio belonging to Westbrook Partners. But, key point here: It’s marketing the 17 buildings not as a portfolio but as individual assets. This is the East Village portfolio that Westbrook Partners bought from Extell in 2007 for $97.5 million.
Massey Knakal is also selling portions of a 46-building portfolio belonging to Praedium. Sources say CB Richard Ellis was originally enlisted to market the portfolio as, well, a portfolio. But then Lehman blew up and the would-be buyer walked away. Praedium and CBRE agreed there was no longer a portfolio market, and CBRE suggested Praedium go to Massey Knakal.
Neither Westbrook nor Praedium would comment for this article. Nor would Robert Knakal, chairman of Massey Knakal, comment on the aforementioned assignments, but he did acknowledge that portfolio sales were no longer viable.
“The reason why the properties are being sold separately in all cases today is because financing is readily available today for small to mid-size properties,” Mr. Knakal said. “Up to $30 million, you can get money from community and regional banks who are still putting a lot of debt into the marketplace. And, because of that, we’ve seen a significant shift in the buyer profile, where the buyer has gone from a local operator with institutional capital behind him to a high-net-worth individual or families that have been investing for decades and they’re investing all their own equity.”
Back during the heyday, investors liked portfolio buys because they provided, in Mr. Schechtman’s words, “critical mass.”
“If you are able to get a lot of similar product close together, managing it becomes more efficient,” he said. “The problem is buyers paid a premium for the portfolio sale, based on the critical mass and the projected upward growth. These days, a valid pro forma incorporates some form of negative growth, a phenomenon we haven’t witnessed for nearly a decade.”
Another part of the portfolio sale’s allure is that it allowed for landlords to get blanket financing, said Peter Decheser, managing director of the Capital Markets Group for Jones Lang LaSalle in New York City. “So in a sense, the value of the portfolio, from a leveraging point of view, was far greater when purchased as a portfolio than as individual assets.”
Thanks to the wizardry of modern-day financing, the purchaser could then assign whatever value he wanted to the individual assets within the portfolio. If he desired, and he often did, he could put a higher value on a nonperforming asset, and a lower value on a performing asset.
“Therefore, if he wanted to spin off a better-performing asset, he could spin it off and show a loss and not have a capital-gains exposure,” Mr. DeCheser said. Brilliant!
“Because it was blanket financing, banks didn’t care how you spread the values around,” Mr. DeCheser said.
Needless to say, “Now they do.”
drubinstein@observer.com