Emmys Observed: tvDownload’s Picks for Best Actor/Actress in Comedy

Where tvDownload’s Drew and Vinnie open up the floor to discuss the picks for this year’s Emmys! <b>Lead Actor</b> Ricky Gervais, <em>Derek</em> Don Cheadle, <em>House of Lies</em> Louis CK, <em>Louie</em> Jim Parson, <em>The Big Bang Theory</em> Matt LeBlanc, <em>Episodes</em> <b>Lead Actress</b> Amy Poehler, <em>Parks and Recreation </em> Melissa McCarthy, <em>Mike and Molly</em> Lena Dunham, <em>GIRLS</em> Edie Falco, <em>Nurse Jackie</em> Julia Louis-Dreyfus, <em>Veep</em> Taylor Schilling, <em>Orange is the New Black</em>

“You’ve lost to Mike & Molly, ma’am.” (HBO)

Where tvDownload’s Drew and Vinnie open up the floor to discuss the picks for this year’s Emmys!

Sign Up For Our Daily Newsletter

By clicking submit, you agree to our <a rel="nofollow noreferer" href="http://observermedia.com/terms">terms of service</a> and acknowledge we may use your information to send you emails, product samples, and promotions on this website and other properties. You can opt out anytime.

See all of our newsletters

Lead Actor
Ricky Gervais, Derek
Don Cheadle, House of Lies
Louis CK, Louie
Jim Parson, The Big Bang Theory
Matt LeBlanc, Episodes

Lead Actress
amy poehler, Parks and Recreation
Melissa McCarthy, Mike and Molly
Lena Dunham, GIRLS
Edie Falco, Nurse Jackie
Julia Louis-Dreyfus, Veep
Taylor Schilling, Orange is the New Black

Vinnie: It really amuses me to no end that you have not one but two guys nominated, not for the first time mind you, for playing a slightly more ridiculous versions of themselves — CK and LeBlanc. It amuses me even more that neither have won for doing so. This year, LeBlanc has a better chance because as good as LOUIE is, CK doesn’t really do a whole ton of acting on it. I don’t think there’d be much of a difference if someone just followed Louis CK around the Lower East Side for a month with a camera.

But in the grand scheme of things, I don’t think either really has a chance. I can’t speak much for Cheadle or Gervais’ performances this year (besides that I wish Gervais was hosting just for pure cheekiness), but what I CAN say is PLEASE DEAR LORD NOT Jim Parsons. He’s already won three times for this role, back to back in 2010 and 2011. BUT WHY? If it is one thing I will never understand it is the universal love for The Big Bang Theory. Actually please, someone out there who is in on it, go down to the comments and explain to me the appeal of that show. I’ll wait.

The funny thing about Lead Actress is that out of the many, many fine women nominated for Orange is the New Black I think Taylor Schilling is the least likely to win. I think we all know by now Piper Chapman is something something Trojan Horse but I don’t think we needed to know that to realize that she is the least interesting person on that show.

Lena Dunham should definitely, definitely win. Oh, not for GIRLS, but for that crazy lipsync to Sia’s Chandelier on Seth Meyers. Who is hosting which means they should totally do that again.
[youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sj757ishXnQ]

Drew: Look Vinnie, I think you need to check your work because you spelled SO MANY of these shows wrong!

Lead Actor in Comedy

Louis CK, Louie
Don Cheadle, House of Something Else Besides Cards
Ricky Gervais, Netflix (NFLX) Frowny-Face
Matt Leblanc, Joey
William H. Macy, Ashamed to Miss It
Jim Parsons, Bazinga the Musical

Please take more care in the future!

Molly: If Julia Louis-Dreyfus doesn’t win, I hereby sentence all voters to a lifetime of Mike and Molly reruns.
unnamed (1)
I mean really, how is this even a competition? Who can compare?
Also, I think Louis CK will prob win for actor… It seems like there was an unspoken agreement this year that he became part of the canon of “respected male entertainers.”

Matthew Kassel: Louis for actor!
And Julia for actress!
julia (1)

Drew: I don’t know you guys. Sometimes it’s the most unlikely of candidates…
The really sad part is that we know who is going to win and we’re gonna all be like “Damn, should have seen that coming.”

Jack Smith: Ricky Gervais should take it for Derek. If you didn’t cry like a brat at nearly every episode, there’s something wrong with your eyes. Besides, he took an opportunity to not play a smarmy, wailing, god-hating sociopath for a single TV-show/movie, and we should reward that behavior.

For Actress:
download (6)

Sarah Devlin: I am saying Julia Louis-Dreyfus again for Veep  (because she’s still on fire right now). Also, Melissa McCarthy needs to stop getting nominated for Emmys based on her movie performances.

For actor maybe William H. Macy? People like giving him stuff.

Drew: What movies are you referring to, Sarah? Tammy?

Sarah Devlin: Bridesmaids. Still.

Emmys Observed: tvDownload’s Picks for Best Actor/Actress in Comedy