Katy Perry Is a Modern Day Gertrude Stein

Katy Perry wrote a grammatically confusing sentence on Twitter which had many who read it furrowing their brows in confusion.

Katy Perry. (Photo: Getty Images)
Katy Perry. (Photo: Getty Images)

Katy Perry wrote a grammatically confusing sentence on Twitter this afternoon that had many who read it furrowing their brows.

Sign Up For Our Daily Newsletter

By clicking submit, you agree to our <a rel="nofollow noreferer" href="http://observermedia.com/terms">terms of service</a> and acknowledge we may use your information to send you emails, product samples, and promotions on this website and other properties. You can opt out anytime.

See all of our newsletters

The message was ostensibly composed as a rebuke to Taylor Swift, who got into a highly publicized Twitter spat this week with Nicki Minaj. Ms. Minaj felt that she had been snubbed by the Video Music Awards, which didn’t nominate her song “Anaconda” for Best Video, and she tweeted out her frustration last night.

Ms. Swift, who was nominated, seemed to take it personally.

That’s the gist. Ms. Perry didn’t state why she was jumping into the battle, though it’s likely it has to do with a fight she got into with Ms. Swift last year when the pop star accused Ms. Perry of wooing away three back-up dancers. (It has been speculated that Ms. Swift had Ms. Perry in mind when she wrote “Bad Blood.”)

Aside from the fact that Ms. Perry seemed to be publicly shaming Ms. Swift, what had most people talking was the syntactical weirdness of the tweet itself. When I showed it to a colleague to see if he understood it, for instance, he first asked who the “pit women” were and then wondered about the “parade argument.”

The key to understanding the tweet is to see the words “parade” and “about” as sandwiching the phrase “the pit women against other women argument.” Here’s a stab at punctuating the sentence: Finding it ironic to parade the pit-women-against-other-women argument about as one unmeasurably capitalizes on the takedown of a woman…

Still doesn’t make much sense, I guess, though after a few reads you do adjust to the warped grammar and it starts to come together, much in the same way Gertrude Stein’s “Composition as Explanation” makes sense only after you’ve read it more than once.

Katy Perry Is a Modern Day Gertrude Stein