Sheldon Silver’s Anointed Heir Ousted In Primary

Yuh-Line Niou defeated Alice Cancel to take over Sheldon Silver's Lower Manhattan seat.

Yuh-Line Niou.
Yuh-Line Niou.

Disgraced ex-Assemblyman Sheldon Silver’s long reign in Lower Manhattan is finally over—voters booted his favored successor from his old seat tonight, instead picking a relative newcomer to the district supported by much of the larger Democratic establishment.

Sign Up For Our Daily Newsletter

By clicking submit, you agree to our <a rel="noreferrer" href="">terms of service</a> and acknowledge we may use your information to send you emails, product samples, and promotions on this website and other properties. You can opt out anytime.

See all of our newsletters

Yuh-Line Niou beat newly-minted Assemblywoman Alice Cancel for the seat spanning the Lower East Side, the Financial District and Chinatown. Today’s primary race was a rematch of the special election Cancel won in April—where Silver’s lackeys secured the longtime district leader the Democratic line, leaving Niou to campaign on the Working Families Party line.

Niou, the ex-chief-of-staff to Assemblyman Ron Kim and a three-year resident of the district, retained much of the coalition of labor unions and city and state Democratic Party leaders that supported her unsuccessful bid in the special election. The strength of Yuh-Line’s fundraising and political backing owes much to Congressman Joseph Crowley, the Queens County Democratic boss, and his ally John Liu, the former city comptroller.

Crowley has now extended his reach to Manhattan—even as a challenger he supported against rebellious Queens State Senator James Sanders appears to have lost badly.

With upward of 90 percent of the vote in, Cancel appears to have placed next-to-last in today’s six-way Democratic primary, drawing fewer than 1,000 votes beating out only local community board chairwoman Gigi Li, an attache of Chinatown Councilwoman Margaret Chin. By contrast, Niou appears to have pulled almost 2,500 votes.

District leader Jenifer Rajkumar looks to have come in a distant second, trailing Niou by 1,000 votes. Paul Newell, Silver’s 2008 primary opponent, came in a few hundred votes behind Rajkumar.

The general election will take place in November, but the Democratic primary winner is virtually assured of victory in the deep-blue district.

Sheldon Silver’s Anointed Heir Ousted In Primary