We Taste Tested Rocket Fizz’s 18 Weirdest Sodas

Stalinade (not to be confused with Leninade) didn't win

Sign Up For Our Daily Newsletter

By clicking submit, you agree to our <a href="http://observermedia.com/terms">terms of service</a> and acknowledge we may use your information to send you emails, product samples, and promotions on this website and other properties. You can opt out anytime.

See all of our newsletters

Rocket Fizz is a chain of stores that boasts more sodas than you can count—so we didn’t really bother to. Last month, a visit to the Austin location produced three flavors that could only be sampled before being discarded (thanks, TSA!):

  • Barf! Soda (“Great chunky flavor!”) tasted like a mild peach, and was actually good.
  • Dirt Soda (“Shoveled & Bottled in the USA”) was like a very strong bitter tea.
  • Grass Soda (“Mowed & Bottled in the USA”) was soapy and green.
Lined up and ready to taste.
Lined up and ready to taste.

A couple of months ago a Rocket Fizz opened in nearby Levittown, which granted Observer an opportunity to bring the 18 most eye-catching bottles to the office and reward/punish our staff with a blind taste test. Some of these are produced by Rocket Fizz themselves, with several indie drink-makers mixed in (with links). Here were the results, from worst to best:

  1. Lester’s Fixins Ranch Dressing Soda: Smells like blue cheese, really gross like something turned in the bottle. Tastes horrific, again like blue cheese but not right for this context.
  2. Lester’s Fixins Sweet Corn Soda: Tastes just like corn and butter. Not anywhere near as good as those buttered popcorn Jelly Belly. Spot on but that isn’t a good thing in this case.
  3. Ginseng UP Original: This is actually a legacy brand, with a few different flavors in the line. The tag line “the root of all power” is great, but the flavor (though unique) is not. Instead it’s bitter and tastes like a certain medicine that is hard to place.
  4. Lester’s Fixins Bacon Soda: Not good. A woodsy flavor that almost tastes like drinking cologne. It is as if they ground up hickory chips used for barbecuing and flavored a soda with it.
  5. Lester’s Fixins Peanut Butter & Jelly Soda: Smells like a teen girl’s perfume. Medicinal and chalky, it was like chugging Tums.
  6. Tractor Soda Co. Lemongrass: Tastes like pure soap, and not the nice kind like, say, those old-fashioned flowery breath mints.
    Rocket Fizz's weirdest sodas.
    Rocket Fizz’s weirdest sodas.
  7. Dos Amigos Burros Churro Churros Soda: Like Chloraseptic. Nothing cinnamon whatsoever.
  8. Fidel Castro’s Havana Banana: Like those banana Runts candy that everyone either loves or loathes.
  9. Scotty’s Butterscotch Soda: Like cheap, bitter butterscotch candy. Worse than those little individually cellophane-wrapped ones that grandma has.
  10. Nuclear Orange Bomb: Simply a very watered-down Sunkist.
  11. Stalinade: Not to be confused with Leninade, get it? Barely had any taste. Like a diluted Cherry 7-Up.
  12. San Francisco Fog Soda: Like cheap sugar with a metallic note. Smells nice, however, and probably the coolest to display as it does look like bottled fog.
  13. Cock Cola: Just like RC or some other off-brand cola. Harsh on the back of the tongue. The name is clever if you’re a teen.
  14. Boylan Shirley Temple: Boylan is a popular second-tier soda company, but their Shirley Temple is almost impossible to find. Sweet, mild and innocuous. Does not taste like a real Shirley Temple, but would make a great mixer.
  15. Dos Amigos Rosa’s Arroz con Leche Sweet Rice Soda: Very mild, like a pure sugar-flavored soda. Not overly cloying.
  16. Reading Draft Grape Smoothie: Like a watered-down grape Jolly Rancher, which makes the sweetness very pleasant instead of overpowering. The beer-like dark bottle and classy label elevate this one.
  17. Sioux City Prickly Pear Soda: Smells quite perfumey. Tart, sweet and soapy. Like a lavender lemonade. This one is very good and unique.
  18. Ozark Mountain Bottleworks Ozark Mountain Lemonade: Smells and tastes like a tarter, more refined Sprite. Simply excellent. The best of the batch.

We Taste Tested Rocket Fizz’s 18 Weirdest Sodas