J.K. Rowling Is Helping This Black Scottish Feminist Take on Twitter Trolls

After Claire Heuchan was trolled over a controversial op-ed, the Harry Potter author leapt to her defense

Scottish feminist writer Claire Heuchan. Twitter

A black feminist researcher who retreated from Twitter after a column she wrote incited hysteria from trolls has returned to the social network—and made friends with J.K. Rowling in the process.

Sign Up For Our Daily Newsletter

By clicking submit, you agree to our <a rel="nofollow noreferer" href="http://observermedia.com/terms">terms of service</a> and acknowledge we may use your information to send you emails, product samples, and promotions on this website and other properties. You can opt out anytime.

See all of our newsletters

Claire Heuchan, a PhD candidate at Scotland’s Stirling University, published an op-ed in The Guardian last week about the parallels between Scottish nationalism and racism. Heuchan, a black woman and self-proclaimed “radical feminist,” endorsed London Mayor Sadiq Khan’s view that “both mentalities are defined by a politics of us and them…trying to divide us on the basis of background, race or religion.”

Khan and Heuchan’s arguments are drawn from Scotland’s history of profiting off the slave trade, along with the memory of the country’s tense 2014 independence vote. Personal experience also plays a role—when Khan ran for mayor last year, he was subjected to Islamophobic attacks claiming that London would be unsafe in his hands.

‘There is a certain irony to white people with progressive politics rubbishing what an Asian man has to say about racism,” Heuchan (who did not respond to an Observer request for comment) wrote.

Heuchan, who blogs and tweets under the name Sister Outrider, was subjected to racist taunts on both platforms over her stance—some trolls deleted their posts, but she took screenshots of them for posterity:

After this series of explosive interactions, Heuchan took a break from Twitter for almost six days.

“Disagreement is fine—healthy, even—but racist abuse is not,” she told the Observer in an email.

But Heuchan returned yesterday, with a vengeance:

“They wanted my voice to be gone, for me to be absent,” she said. “Giving them that level of control over my life felt absolutely horrible. People will still hold racist views, still behave in a racist fashion, unless it is brought out into the open and critiqued.”

Heuchan revealed today that she had reported “numerous” nationalist trolls to the Scottish police for abusive and racist behavior. She also gave one last defense of her Guardian piece (go to her Twitter account for the full thread):

There was one silver lining to the week of online abuse, however—Heuchan gained a very famous follower:

Rowling had Heuchan’s back when she returned from her self-imposed Twitter exile:

And today, when Heuchan gave her final impassioned defense, Rowling went public with her support of the harassed writer:

Ironically, while the racist trolls have gotten the most publicity, Heuchan said that most reactions to her article were very similar to Rowling’s.

“So many people have written to say they agree with my article but are too afraid to say so publicly, which is very telling,” she said. “Even friends who are nationalists have said that it is food for thought, and that’s even better than straight agreement.”

Here’s hoping that Heuchan’s A-list new friend will make the trolls disappear like magic.

J.K. Rowling Is Helping This Black Scottish Feminist Take on Twitter Trolls