Democrats Take Grenier to Court Over Political Contribution

Fran Grenier, left, and Jon Bramnick. Fran Grenier via Facebook

As Senate President Steve Sweeney battles the New Jersey Education Association for his Senate seat, Democrats took his GOP challenger, Fran Grenier, to court this week and claimed he violated campaign disclosure law as Salem County Republican Committee chairman.

The NJEA’s war with Sweeney has shattered spending records for a legislative race, and a Republican internal poll obtained by Observer this month showed Sweeney’s lead over Grenier slimming to single digits.

On Monday, two Salem County Democrats filed a lawsuit against Grenier over a $189,000 contribution the GOP county committee reported in July to the state Election Law Enforcement Commission. The committee later removed all references to the contribution in an October amendment to the report after Democrats questioned its legality, according to the suit. The complaint alleges Grenier and the GOP county committee treasurer “conspired to evade” campaign contribution limits.

The plaintiffs, Salem Democratic Committee Chairman Steven Caltabiano and Salem County freeholder candidate Charles Hassler, are represented by Bill Tambussi, a close ally of Sweeney and South Jersey power broker George Norcross.

Although Sweeney is not listed as a plaintiff, Senate Republican Majority Executive Director Harrison Neely attacked Sweeney and questioned his ethics.

“His campaign doesn’t have a leg to stand on here. He is a legislator and a lobbyist,” Neely said, repeating a claim made in the NJEA’s attack ads against Sweeney. “I don’t think they are coming out with this with a whole lot of credibility.”

The legal issue stems from a $189,000 contribution the Salem County Republican Committee said it received in March from the trust of the estate of James X. Farish, a Penns Grove Republican who died 13 years ago, according to the suit. Farish had originally left part of his estate to the Reagan Republican Club of Penns Grove, which was terminated in January, before transferring the trust to the Salem County Republicans, the suit said.

Democrats argue the initial 2004 contribution of the trust to the local Republican club grossly exceeded the $7,200 individual donation limit to a municipal political party committee, and that the Penns Grove club never reported funds from the trust.

After Caltabiano filed a complaint with ELEC in July over the club’s contribution to Salem County Republicans, the GOP committee amended its quarterly report in October and removed references of the contribution, ELEC forms included in the lawsuit show. ELEC has not yet acted in response to Caltabiano’s complaints, according to the suit.

On Thursday, state Superior Court Judge David Morgan blocked Salem County Republicans and Grenier from spending any funds originating from the trust and referred the case to ELEC. Morgan also ruled Grenier and GOP county committee treasurer Jessica Bishop must provide a complete accounting of the Farish trust.

“The court today affirmed that schemes to funnel illegal campaign contributions by political party bosses like Fran Grenier will not be permitted,” Tambussi said in a statement. “The blatant attempt to mislead the voters in Salem County failed and the playing field was leveled by today’s decision.”

Neely dismissed the ruling was meaningless, saying the contribution is “not having an impact on the race now.”

The NJEA, the state’s largest teacher’s union, has spent more than $4 million to take out Sweeney, the state’s top Democrat, and spending on the 3rd district Senate race had reached $9.5 million as of Oct. 6, according to the ELEC analysis. Grenier trails by 6 points and has been closing the gap over the last month, according to an internal poll taken by Republicans.

Democrats Take Grenier to Court Over Political Contribution